top of page
Search

Part 1A - In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings, Attribute Methodology

  • Dr.D
  • Dec 30, 2023
  • 19 min read

Updated: Mar 25, 2024

TABLE OF CONTENTS

PART 1A


  • Introduction

  • Summary Methodology

    • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Rankings, Summary Methodology (Full Format)

      • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Total Score Rankings

    • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Rankings, Summary Methodology (List Format)

      • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Total Score Rankings

      • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Offense & Toughness Rankings

      • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Offense Rankings

      • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Toughness Rankings

      • In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Enemy Debuff Rankings

  • Related Articles

INTRODUCTION


Army General Analysis PART 1A, reviewing In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP Generals (for Battlefield, KE, SvS and/or Purge).


Note: There are DIFFERENT In-City Defense (Main Wall) Generals for PEACE-TIME that are covered in Part 11.


Takenaka Shigeharu is much, much stronger than the other Army Generals in this category, so it's making the rankings a bit wonky.


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Army General Troop Specialties


  • Anti-Ground (Mounted Focused) Lead Generals: Queen Boudica, Yi Sun-sin, and Jadwiga

  • Anti-Ranged (Ground Focused) Generals: Leonidas I, Lautaro, Oda Oichi, Robert the Bruce, James Bowie, and Shajar al-Durr.

  • Anti-Mounted (Ranged Focused) Generals: Yodo-dono, Zachary Taylor, George Dewey, Kusunoki Masashige, and Ly Thuong Kiet

  • Anti-Siege (Siege Focused) Generals: Takenaka Shigeharu, Leo III, William Marshal, Richard the Lionheart, Gustavus Adolphus, and Raged King

ATTRIBUTE METHODOLOGY - v4.1.1


Attribute Ranking Methodology


The EvonyAnswers (EvAns) Attribute Ranking System will tend to favor Offense (Attack & March Size) over Toughness (HP & Defense). It also tends to favor Army Generals with good Enemy Debuffs.


There's a multiplier for each Attribute to achieve the approximate Score Weightings listed below. All the multipliers are applied the same way to all Army General Attributes in each specific category.


Attribute Categories:

  • Basic Attributes Score - Leadership, Attack, Defense, & Politics.

  • Base Skill Score - Also known as the "Built-In" Skill Score.

  • Four (4) Skill Books - For the Lead General's Best Four (4) Possible Skill Books.

  • Specialties Score - As appropriate for that Specific Ranking, i.e. 4-Yellow, 3-Orange, 3-Purple, etc.)

  • Ascending Enhancement Score - only added for the Ascending Enhancement Rankings.




Please check out the article below for a more detailed explanation:






In-City Defense (Main Wall) Score Weightings


Previous Version


Approximate Score Weightings for In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Rankings, Attribute Methodology v3 were:


In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP v3:

  • In-City Defense Offense (Attack Increase): 49%

  • In-City Defense Toughness (HP & Defense Increase): 49%

  • Enemy Debuffs: 1%

  • Other Stuff:  1%


Current Version


Approximate Score Weightings for In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Rankings, Attribute Methodology v4 are:


In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP v4:

  • In-City Defense Offense (Attack Increase): 44%

  • In-City Defense Toughness (HP & Defense Increase): 54%

  • Enemy Debuffs: 1%

  • Other Stuff: 1%

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP RANKINGS, ATTRIBUTE METHODOLOGY (FEATURED FORMAT) - v4.1.1


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP RANKINGS


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings (at Maximum Ascending Enhancements and 4-Yellow Specialties Level)



1. Takenaka Shigeharu - Grade: A+ (100.0% - 1258) - By far, the strongest In-City Defense General. Sometimes Evony releases a new Army General that's so far ahead of the other Generals in the same category that it seems like a mistake. This is the case with Takenaka Shigeharu.

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but strongest against Enemy Siege Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF2

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: EXTREMELY DIFFICULT, he’s NOT available in the Epic Historic General (Premium) tokens, which are most commonly found in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100 US). He’s only available occasionally through pay events such as the highest level of the King’s Party Cake Bonus (which typically requires buying the 5th event packs ($100 US) every day of the Special Event, that’s about $2,000 US).

  • Culture: Japan

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: June, 2023

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+251% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +155% (+205% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+249% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +210%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +30% (+286% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +210%



2. Leo III - Grade: B+ (84.9% - 1068)

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but strongest against Enemy Siege and Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF1A

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: DIFFICULT, available in the Epic Historic General (Premium) tokens, which are most commonly found in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100).

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: October, 2021

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +20% (+266% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +162% (+212% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +20% (+270% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +70%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +20% (+270% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +100%



T-3. William Marshal - Grade: B+ (84.6% - 1064)

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but strongest against Enemy Siege and Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF3

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: DIFFICULT, available in the Epic Historic General (Premium) tokens, which are most commonly found in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100).

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: December, 2021

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+254% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +220% (+270% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+250% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +120%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+248% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +120%



T-3. Leonidas I - Grade: B+ (84.6% - 1064)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Ranged and Mounted Attacks, he’s a strong defender against Ranged Troop Attacks (the most common type of PvP attack).

  • Conflict Group: DF4A

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: DIFFICULT, available in the Epic Historic General (Premium) tokens, which are most commonly found in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100).

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: June, 2021

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +0% (+240% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +215% (+265% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+254% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +150%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+260% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +70%



5. Lautaro - Grade: B+ (83.9% - 1056)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Ranged and Ground Attacks. He’s a strong defender against Ranged Troop Attacks (by far, the most common type of PvP attack) and Ground Attacks (by far, the most common type of attack from All-Star Level opponents).

  • Conflict Group: DF6

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: DIFFICULT, available in the Epic Historic General (Premium) tokens, which are most commonly found in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100).

  • Culture: Other

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: January, 2023

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +0% (+251% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +210% (+260% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+249% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +80%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+246% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +130%



6. Yodo-dono - Grade: B (80.8% - 1017)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF4

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: EXTREMELY DIFFICULT, she’s NOT available in the Epic Historic General (Premium) tokens, which are most commonly found in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100 US). She’s only available occasionally through pay events such as the highest level of the King’s Party Cake Bonus (which typically requires buying the 5th event packs ($185 US) every day of the Special Event, that’s about $2,100 US).

  • Culture: Japan

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: August, 2022

  • Recommended Specialty Level: Maybe 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +12% (+257% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +110% (+160% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +35% (+281% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +40%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +30% (+283% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +35%



T-7. Zachary Taylor - Grade: B (80.1% - 1008)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF4

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY, as of 06-23-2023, available in the Relic Chamber Rewards (RCR) Activity.

  • Culture: America

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: January, 2021

  • Recommended Specialty Level: Maybe 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+245% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +237% (+287% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+247% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +130%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+248% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +150%



T-7. George Dewey - Grade: B (80.1% - 1008)

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but strongest against Enemy Siege and Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF3A

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: CHALLENGING, available in the Great General’s Chest (GGC) Activity.

  • Culture: America

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: First introduced sometime before January, 2018, as Joseph P. Johnson, then name changed to George Dewey on 02-14-2022.

  • Recommended Specialty Level: Maybe 4-Yellow

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+245% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +237% (+287% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+247% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +130%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+248% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +150%



9. Queen Boudica - Grade: B- (77.2% - 971)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Ground Attacks, but also does ok against Enemy Ranged Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF5

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above). Available in the Tavern as of 07-15-2022, she's probably the best option available in the Tavern. Also, still available in the Great General’s Chest (GGC) Activity.

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: Unknown (before January, 2018)

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 3-Orange or less

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+248% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +116% (+166% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+246% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +216%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+237% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +130%



10. Richard the Lionheart - Grade: B- (76.7% - 965) – Mostly a hospital expander, but can be a reasonable option if ALL of his Ascending Enhancements are developed.

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks.

  • Conflict Group: NG

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above), probably the 2nd best option available in the Tavern, but only if ALL of his Ascending Enhancements are developed.

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: Unknown (before January, 2018)

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 3-Orange or less

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +25% (+247% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +30% (+80% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +55% (+311% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +20%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +50% (+303% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +20%



11. Oda Oichi - Grade: B- (76.5% - 962)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Ranged Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF1

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: DIFFICULT, only available in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100) and possibly during the King’s Scheme, Ekaterina’s Garden, King’s Party, or other pay events.

  • Culture: Japan

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: May, 2022

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 3-Orange or less

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +55% (+298% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +20% (+70% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+244% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +130%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+254% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +30%



12. Kusunoki Masashige - Grade: B- (75.6% - 951)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Mounted Attacks, but also does ok against Enemy Ground Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF4B

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above). Available in the Tavern as of 07-15-2022, he's probably the 3rd best option available in the Tavern. As of 06-23-2023, no longer available in the Relic Chamber Rewards (RCR) Activity.

  • Culture: Japan

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: August, 2020

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 3-Orange or less

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+247% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +130% (+180% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +30% (+281% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +20%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +25% (+269% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +10%



13. Yi Sun-sin - Grade: C+ (73.9% - 930)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Ground and Ranged Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF1B

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: DIFFICULT, only available in the 5th Daily Event Packs ($100) and possibly during the King’s Scheme, Ekaterina’s Garden, King’s Party, or other pay events. As of 06-23-2023, no longer available in the Relic Chamber Rewards (RCR) Activity.

  • Culture: Korea

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: May, 2020

  • Recommended Specialty Level: 3-Orange or less

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +37% (+277% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +120% (+170% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+249% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +30%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+247% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +60%



14. Jadwiga - Grade: C+ (71.5% - 900)

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but especially strong against Enemy Siege and Ground Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF5A

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above). Available in the Tavern as of 07-15-2022, she's probably the 4th best option available in the Tavern.

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: February, 2020

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, she’s probably not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +0% (+231% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +181% (+231% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+249% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +90%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+237% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +120%



15. Robert the Bruce - Grade: C (71.2% - 896)

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Ranged and Ground Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF7

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above). Available in the Tavern as of 07-15-2022, he's probably the 5th best option available in the Tavern. He's also 1 of the 8 Army Generals available in the Europe Epic Historic General Chest at level 50 in the Dawn of Civilization Event ($20 for easy mode, or $5 if you work hard and complete every task or spend gems for the last few levels).

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Ground Troops

  • Introduced: November, 2020

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, he’s probably not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+250% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +140% (+190% w/ Skill Books)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+250% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +100%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+249% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +30%



16. James Bowie - Grade: C (70.5% - 887)

  • Specialist Against: Primarily Enemy Ranged Attacks, but also does ok against Enemy Ground Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF6

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above). Available in the Tavern as of 01-27-2022, he's probably the 6th best option available in the Tavern.

  • Culture: America

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: February, 2019

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, he’s not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+244% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +152% (+202% w/ Skill Book)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+239% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +90%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+243% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +100%



17. Ly Thuong Kiet - Grade: C (69.3% - 872) - Has a very high trap trigger buff, but currently the game just isn’t set up to favor having a strong trap defense.

  • Specialist Against: Enemy Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF8

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above), probably the 7th best option available in the Tavern.

  • Culture: Other

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: Unknown (before January, 2018)

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, he’s not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +6% (+239% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +106% (+156% w/ Skill Book)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+244% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +110%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+242% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +150%



18. Tran Hung Dao - Grade: C (68.8% - 865)

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but stronger against Enemy Siege and Ranged Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF2A

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above), probably the 8th best option available in the Tavern.

  • Culture: Other

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: Unknown (before January, 2018)

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, he’s not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +0% (+234% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +120% (+170% w/ Skill Book)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+237% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +135%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+240% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +125%



19. Shajar al-Durr - Grade: C (67.6% - 851) – She is the best (and only) option for Peace-Time In-City Defense (Main Wall) General, but can be a descent PvP option if ALL of her Ascending Enhancements are developed.

  • Specialist Against: Strongest against Enemy Ranged Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: NG

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: CHALLENGING, available in the Great General’s Chest (GGC).

  • Culture: Arabia

  • Expertise: Main City Defense (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: November, 2018

  • Recommended Specialty Level: For most people, 3-Purple or less. However, she is the best (and only) option for Peace-Time In-City Defense (Main Wall) General. The problem is that her 4th Specialty is not that great. If her 4th Specialty was 200% Resource Production Increase, instead of 200% Food Protected from Troop Upkeep, maybe it would be worth the Runestones. Even if it was so, there are probably better places to spend Runestones.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +35% (+263% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +20% (+70% w/ Skill Book)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +35% (+276% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +10%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +40% (+281% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +10%



20. Gustavus Adolphus - Grade: D+ (59.4% - 747) – Not specifically a Main Wall Army General, but has Skills and Specialties that make him a reasonable temporary choice if nothing better is available. He’s a reasonable PvP option, but probably not a good permanent solution because his 4th Specialty will NOT work when he’s an In-City Defense (Main Wall) General.

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but strongest against Enemy Siege and Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: DF9

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: Relatively EASY (at Tavern Level 27 and above), probably the 9th best option available in the Tavern.

  • Culture: Europe

  • Expertise: Mixed Troops (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: Unknown (before January, 2018)

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, he’s not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +0% (+244% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +152% (+202% w/ Skill Book)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+248% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +82%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+230% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +10%



21. Raged King - Grade: D+ (55.4% - 697) - It seems like he’s more of a prize for the General’s Gallery I in the Art Hall.

  • Specialist Against: All types of enemy attacks, but strongest against Enemy Siege and Mounted Attacks.

  • Conflict Group: NG

  • Dragon: Not Required

  • Covenant: No

  • Acquisition: EXTREMELY DIFFICULT, he’s only available on the Wheel of Fortune, and the odds of getting him are about 1 in 100,000 spins.

  • Culture: Other

  • Expertise: Mixed Troops (Currently No Category in Senate)

  • Introduced: Unknown (before January, 2018)

  • Recommended Specialty Level: None, he’s not worth investing Runestones because there are superior choices available in the Tavern and as Relic Chamber Rewards.

In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs:

  1. Defending Attack

    1. All Troop Attack Increase: +20% (+255% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Attack Increase: +65% (+115% w/ Skill Book)

  2. Defending HP

    1. All Troop HP Increase: +0% (+244% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop HP Increase: +45%

  3. Defending Defense

    1. All Troop Defense Increase: +0% (+226% w/ Basic Attribute)

    2. Single Troop Defense Increase: +35%

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP RANKINGS, ATTRIBUTE METHODOLOGY (LIST FORMAT) - v4.1.1


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP, ASCENDING ENHANCEMENT RANKINGS


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings (at maximum [10-Star] Ascending Enhancements and 4-Yellow Specialties Level)


  1. Takenaka Shigeharu - Grade: A+ (100.0% - 1258)

  2. Leo III - Grade: B+ (84.9% - 1068)

  3. William Marshal - Grade: B+ (84.6% - 1064)

  4. Leonidas I - Grade: B+ (84.6% - 1064)

  5. Lautaro - Grade: B+ (83.9% - 1056)

  6. Yodo-dono - Grade: B (80.8% - 1017)

  7. Zachary Taylor - Grade: B (80.1% - 1008)

  8. George Dewey - Grade: B (80.1% - 1008)

  9. Queen Boudica - Grade: B- (77.2% - 971)

  10. Richard the Lionheart - Grade: B- (76.7% - 965)

  11. Oda Oichi - Grade: B- (76.5% - 962)

  12. Kusunoki Masashige - Grade: B- (75.6% - 951)

  13. Yi Sun-sin - Grade: C+ (73.9% - 930)

  14. Jadwiga - Grade: C+ (71.5% - 900)

  15. Robert the Bruce - Grade: C (71.2% - 896)

  16. James Bowie - Grade: C (70.5% - 887)

  17. Ly Thuong Kiet - Grade: C (69.3% - 872)

  18. Tran Hung Dao - Grade: C (68.8% - 865)

  19. Shajar al-Durr - Grade: C (67.6% - 851)

  20. Gustavus Adolphus - Grade: D+ (59.4% - 747)

  21. Raged King - Grade: D+ (55.4% - 697)

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP, 4-YELLOW SPECIALTIES RANKINGS


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings (at 4-Yellow Specialties Level)


  1. Takenaka Shigeharu - Grade: A+ (100.0% - 843)

  2. Leo III - Grade: A (92.1% - 776)

  3. Lautaro - Grade: A- (91.3% - 770)

  4. William Marshal - Grade: A- (89.3% - 753)

  5. Leonidas I - Grade: A- (88.0% - 742)

  6. Robert the Bruce - Grade: B+ (85.5% - 721)

  7. Yodo-dono - Grade: B+ (84.8% - 715)

  8. Zachary Taylor - Grade: B (81.3% - 685)

  9. Oda Oichi - Grade: B (80.8% - 681)

  10. Yi Sun-sin - Grade: B (80.3% - 677)

  11. George Dewey - Grade: B (79.7% - 672)

  12. Queen Boudica - Grade: B- (78.5% - 662)

  13. Kusunoki Masashige - Grade: B- (78.5% - 662)

  14. Ly Thuong Kiet - Grade: C+ (71.9% - 606)

  15. James Bowie - Grade: C+ (71.8% - 605)

  16. Jadwiga - Grade: C (71.4% - 602)

  17. Tran Hung Dao - Grade: C (70.0% - 590)

  18. Gustavus Adolphus - Grade: C (68.6% - 578)

  19. Richard the Lionheart - Grade: D+ (61.1% - 515)

  20. Raged King - Grade: D+ (61.0% - 514)

  21. Shajar al-Durr - Grade: D (51.8% - 437)

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP, 3-ORANGE SPECIALTIES RANKINGS


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings (at 3-Orange Specialties Level)


  1. Takenaka Shigeharu - Grade: A+ (100.0% - 686)

  2. Leonidas I - Grade: A (94.8% - 650)

  3. Lautaro - Grade: A (94.5% - 648)

  4. Yodo-dono - Grade: A (93.0% - 638)

  5. Leo III - Grade: A (92.3% - 633)

  6. William Marshal - Grade: A (92.3% - 633)

  7. Oda Oichi - Grade: A- (89.4% - 613)

  8. Zachary Taylor - Grade: B+ (87.3% - 599)

  9. Robert the Bruce - Grade: B+ (86.7% - 595)

  10. Yi Sun-sin - Grade: B+ (85.6% - 587)

  11. Kusunoki Masashige - Grade: B+ (85.6% - 587)

  12. George Dewey - Grade: B (81.8% - 561)

  13. Gustavus Adolphus - Grade: B (80.3% - 551)

  14. Ly Thuong Kiet - Grade: B- (78.1% - 536)

  15. Queen Boudica - Grade: B- (77.8% - 534)

  16. Jadwiga - Grade: B- (76.7% - 526)

  17. James Bowie - Grade: B- (75.5% - 518)

  18. Tran Hung Dao - Grade: C+ (72.6% - 498)

  19. Richard the Lionheart - Grade: C (70.8% - 486)

  20. Raged King - Grade: C- (66.9% - 459)

  21. Shajar al-Durr - Grade: D+ (61.4% - 421)

IN-CITY DEFENSE (MAIN WALL) PvP, 3-PURPLE SPECIALTIES RANKINGS


In-City Defense (Main Wall) Lead PvP General Rankings (at 3-Purple Specialties Level)


  1. Takenaka Shigeharu - Grade: A+ (100.0% - 673)

  2. Leonidas I - Grade: A (94.7% - 637)

  3. Lautaro - Grade: A (94.1% - 633)

  4. Yodo-dono - Grade: A (93.0% - 626)

  5. William Marshal - Grade: A (92.1% - 620)

  6. Leo III - Grade: A (92.0% - 619)

  7. Oda Oichi - Grade: A- (89.3% - 601)

  8. Zachary Taylor - Grade: B+ (86.9% - 585)

  9. Robert the Bruce - Grade: B+ (86.6% - 583)

  10. Yi Sun-sin - Grade: B+ (85.4% - 575)

  11. Kusunoki Masashige - Grade: B+ (85.1% - 573)

  12. George Dewey - Grade: B (81.4% - 548)

  13. Gustavus Adolphus - Grade: B (79.8% - 537)

  14. Queen Boudica - Grade: B- (79.3% - 534)

  15. Ly Thuong Kiet - Grade: B- (77.7% - 523)

  16. Jadwiga - Grade: B- (76.1% - 512)

  17. James Bowie - Grade: C+ (75.2% - 506)

  18. Tran Hung Dao - Grade: C+ (71.9% - 484)

  19. Richard the Lionheart - Grade: C (70.3% - 473)

  20. Raged King - Grade: C- (66.9% - 450)

  21. Shajar al-Durr - Grade: D+ (61.4% - 413)

RELATED ARTICLES


Related Articles for In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP Generals


Related Support Articles

SKILL BOOKS


Skill Books for In-City Defense (Main Wall) PvP


  • Ground Attack Increase: +25%

  • Ground HP Increase: +25%

  • Ground Defense Increase: +25%

  • Ranged Attack Increase: +25%

  • Ranged HP Increase: +25%

  • Ranged Defense Increase: +25%

  • Ranged Range Bonus: +100

  • Mounted Attack Increase: +25%

  • Mounted HP Increase: +25%

  • Mounted Defense Increase: +25%

  • Siege Attack Increase: +25%

  • Siege HP Increase: +25%

  • Siege Defense Increase: +25%

  • Siege Range Bonus: +200


Use the top six (6) choices from the list of fourteen (14) above. Choices will vary from Keep to Keep depending on individual defense strategy.


Mounted (Movement) Speed Increase and Ground (Movement) Speed Increase do NOT work so don't waste a Skill Book slot on either of those.

DRAGON


Dragon for In-City Defense (Main Wall) General


Whenever possible, Dragons should be placed on PvP Generals (mostly because I hate moving Dragons). VERY few players have five (5) Dragons, so the Dragons should assigned per the following:


  1. Ranged PvP - Celtic Demon (1st Dragon - Red) or upgrade to Ladon (6th Dragon - Turquoise)

  2. Mounted PvP - Fafnir (2nd Dragon - Purple) or upgrade to Nidhogg (5th Dragon - Dark Blue)

  3. In-City Defense (Main Wall) - Dragon of Thebes (4th Dragon - Gold)

  4. Ground PvP - Norway Ridge (3rd Dragon - Light Blue) or upgrade to Amaterasu (7th Dragon - White)

  5. Siege PvP - Fafnir (2nd Dragon - Purple) or upgrade to Colchian (8th Dragon - Green)

  6. Mounted PvM for Pushing - Fafnir (2nd Dragon - Purple)

  7. Subordinate City Battle (PvP) - Norway Ridge (3rd Dragon - Light Blue)


The Dragon of Thebes (4th Dragon - Gold) is typically assigned to the In-City Defense (Main Wall) General because it offers extra In-City Troop Bonuses. Currently, Dragon of Thebes is the only Dragon focusing on the In-City Defense (Main Wall) Buffs.

If you have any comments, requests, or questions, please let me know in the comments section below.


Also, directing my attention to any mistakes is greatly appreciated.


Thanks for Reading,

dr.dur.ri.gi.ble

6 Comments

John Byers
John Byers
Mar 31, 2023

Hi,


what equipment is recommended for wall generals?


Many thanks!

Like
Brian C
Brian C
Jan 12, 2023

What about the new dragon, jawzahr?

Like
cfulbright
May 13, 2022

What skills do you recommend for Leo III beside Siege Attack Increase?

Like
Dr.D
May 24, 2022
Replying to

Sorry, I didn’t see this sooner, I was super busy last week.


I’d recommend Siege Range Bonus, and Ranged Range Bonus. Ranged Attack Increase would also work Instead of Ranged Range Bonus.

Like
cfulbright
May 13, 2022

What are your thoughts on the new Oda Oichi?

Like
Dr.D
May 24, 2022
Replying to

She is middle of the pack, #11 out of 17. I would not recommend anyone use her for more than temporary option until something better is available.

Like

Evony Answers

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

©2021 by dr.dur gaming

bottom of page